We're building the future of agentic promotions. Sign up for early access!
Sign up
We're building the future of agentic promotions. Sign up for early access!
Sign up 
Table of Contents:
Table of Contents:
Most roundups on Shopify membership apps look the same: a list of eight to 12 apps, a few bullet points of features, and a pricing table. What they don’t tell you is which app is actually right for your business type, your perk strategy, or how you plan to retain members past the first renewal.
This list is different. We’ve reviewed eight of the best Shopify membership apps in 2026, matched each one to a specific use case, and flagged the one that goes furthest beyond basic discounts to build real retention. Each entry covers what the app does well, where it falls short, what it costs, and what real Shopify merchants are saying about it.
What this article covers:
| # | App | Rating | Best For | Starting Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 99minds | 5.0/5 | Multi-perk memberships with store credit, loyalty, and gift cards | Free; plans from $49/month |
| 2 | Appstle℠ Memberships | 5.0/5 | High-volume stores needing a polished member portal | Free (up to 25 members); from $19/month |
| 3 | Bold Memberships & Loyalty | 4.3/5 | Members-only access control and price gating | Free (1–10 members); from $9.99/month |
| 4 | Conjured Memberships | 4.8/5 | Perk and content-driven programs | Free dev plan; from $9.99/month |
| 5 | Simplee Memberships & Loyalty | 5.0/5 | Paid loyalty with paywalled content | Free plan; from $9.75/month |
| 6 | Memberply | 5.0/5 | Zero transaction fees, flat-rate billing | $49/month flat |
| 7 | Recurpay | 4.9/5 | Budget-conscious stores just getting started | Free (3.5% fee); from $9/month |
| 8 | Seal Subscriptions | 4.9/5 | Stores wanting subscriptions and memberships in one app | Free; from $4.95/month |
Pricing and ratings reflect what’s current as of July 2026. Verify on the Shopify App Store before making a final decision.
These two terms get used interchangeably, but they mean different things, and choosing the wrong type of app for your goals is a common reason membership programs underperform.
A subscription app handles recurring product delivery. Your customers pay a set fee to receive something: a coffee box every month, a skincare kit on a quarterly schedule. The value is in the product itself.
A membership app handles recurring access and perks. Your customers pay to be part of something: exclusive discounts, early access to products, free shipping, store credit, or member-only content. The value is in belonging.
Some apps handle both (Appstle, Recurpay, and Seal Subscriptions all do). But if your primary goal is rewarding loyal customers and creating a sense of exclusivity, you want an app built for membership, not just delivery scheduling. That’s what this list focuses on.
Not every membership app is built the same way. Before you install one, here’s what actually matters:
Tier and pricing flexibility: Can you create multiple membership levels at different price points, each with its own perks and renewal frequency? A single flat membership works fine for simple programs, but you’ll want tiered options as your program grows.
Perk variety beyond discounts: Discounts and free shipping are table stakes in 2026. The apps that drive real retention let you offer store credit, cashback, exclusive product access, digital content, and loyalty point multipliers. If an app only does discounts, members will stop noticing. For a full picture of what a well-integrated loyalty and membership stack looks like, see our roundup of the best Shopify loyalty apps.
Billing and dunning management: What happens when a renewal payment fails? Apps with smart retry logic and automated member notifications prevent silent churn from bad card data.
Customer portal UX: Your members need to be able to pause, cancel, or upgrade their plan without contacting your support team. A clunky self-service experience increases both churn and support volume.
Integration depth: Does the app connect with your email marketing platform (Klaviyo, Omnisend), your CRM, your POS, and your loyalty tool? The more disconnected your apps are, the more manual work you’ll do.
Pricing model: Some apps take a percentage of your subscription revenue; others charge a flat monthly fee. On a growing store, revenue-percentage models get expensive fast. Factor this in before you commit.
There’s no single “best” membership app. The right choice depends on your business type, your perk strategy, and the tools you already have in your stack.
| Business Type | What You Need | Best Fit |
|---|---|---|
| DTC brand (health, beauty, supplements) | Recurring perks + loyalty points + store credit | 99minds, Appstle |
| Fitness or studio | Tiered access + POS integration | 99minds, Bold |
| Digital content or creator | Content gating + paywalled pages | Conjured, Simplee |
| Food and beverage / CPG | Simple recurring discount + email integration | Recurpay, Seal Subscriptions |
| Multi-channel (online + in-store) | POS sync + member recognition at checkout | 99minds, Bold |
| Just starting out | Free plan with core perk functionality | Recurpay, Appstle (free tier) |
If you’re running a DTC or retail brand that wants memberships to connect with loyalty points, store credit, and gift cards, the list below puts 99minds at the top for exactly that reason.
Several things have changed since most “best membership apps” roundups were last updated, and they affect which app is the right fit today:
Store credit as a membership perk: More merchants are moving beyond flat discounts and offering automatic store credit deposits as a member benefit. Store credit feels more valuable than a discount code, keeps money in your ecosystem, and drives repeat purchases. Apps that support this natively are a meaningful step ahead of those that don’t.
Digital content and community gating: Apps like Conjured Memberships and Simplee now support page-level content restrictions, so members can unlock articles, videos, or downloadable resources that non-members can’t see. This capability is becoming a standard expectation, not a premium feature.
Apple and Google Wallet integration: A membership card that lives in a customer’s digital wallet isn’t just a novelty. It serves as a constant brand touchpoint and reduces friction when redeeming perks in-store. 99minds MemberPass is the clearest example of this in the Shopify ecosystem.
Pricing model shifts: Several apps that previously charged a revenue percentage on top of their monthly fee have moved toward flat-rate plans in 2025 and 2026. Where this shift is relevant to an app on this list, we’ve noted it.
Each app below was evaluated on perk flexibility, billing reliability, pricing transparency, integration depth, and real user ratings pulled from the Shopify App Store.
99minds is built for ecommerce and retail brands that want memberships to work as part of a broader loyalty and rewards system, not as a standalone discount gate. Unlike every other app on this list, 99minds combines 99minds Membership, store credit, loyalty points, gift cards, and referral programs in a single platform.
This means your members don’t just get a discount: they earn points on purchases, receive automatic store credit at renewal, and carry a digital membership card in their Apple or Google Wallet. It works across Shopify, Shopify Plus, BigCommerce, and Salesforce Commerce Cloud, so you’re not locked in if your store migrates or expands to a new sales channel.
It’s particularly well-suited for brands that want their membership program to drive repeat purchases and increase customer lifetime value rather than simply serve as a recurring billing arrangement. The unified dashboard means you’re managing tiers, perks, loyalty rules, and gift card issuance in one place instead of juggling multiple apps and reconciling data across them.
See full details on 99minds Pricing.
With 99minds, run membership tiers, store credit, and loyalty rewards from a single Shopify app
Appstle is one of the most widely used membership apps on Shopify, with over 800 reviews and a consistent 5.0/5 rating. It covers the full membership lifecycle: plan creation, perk configuration, recurring billing, and member portal management, all from a single merchant dashboard. It’s a strong fit for stores that need a polished, scalable member experience without custom development work.
What sets it apart from newer apps in this category is its depth of configurability: you can control exactly what each tier unlocks, set different billing frequencies per plan, and automate tagging rules that update member status in real time. Stores with larger member bases or more complex tier structures tend to gravitate toward Appstle because it handles that scale without requiring developer involvement.
Verify current pricing on the Shopify App Store.
Bold Memberships comes from Bold Commerce, a long-standing Shopify ecosystem company known for its subscription and checkout tools. It’s a good fit for merchants who want straightforward members-only access control: specific products, collections, or price tiers locked behind a paid membership, with recurring billing handled automatically.
The app is particularly useful for brands that are already running Bold Subscriptions or Bold Checkout, since the integrations are tight and the merchant interface stays consistent across the suite. If you need a membership layer that slots neatly into an existing Bold stack rather than a standalone solution, it’s a natural starting point.
Verify current plan structure and pricing on the Shopify App Store.
Conjured is purpose-built for perk-driven and content-gated membership programs. If you want to lock specific pages, products, or digital content behind a paid membership tier, Conjured is one of the strongest options in the Shopify ecosystem. It’s also developer-friendly, with a clean API and customization options for merchants who want a tailored member experience.
This makes it a popular choice for brands selling early access to product drops, exclusive editorial content, or digital downloads as part of a paid tier. The 30-day free trial on all paid plans gives merchants enough runway to validate their membership model before committing to a monthly fee.
All plans include a 30-day free trial. Verify current pricing and plan features on the Shopify App Store.
Simplee combines paid membership management with loyalty-style perks, making it a hybrid option for brands that want members to earn credits and rewards alongside their access benefits. It supports free trials on membership plans, which can reduce signup friction and give potential members a lower-stakes way to commit.
This combination of access control, earned rewards, and content gating makes Simplee a versatile choice for brands that sit somewhere between a pure-access membership (like a club) and a pure-loyalty program (like a points scheme). It’s also one of the more approachable apps on this list for non-technical store owners, with a setup flow that doesn’t require touching Shopify’s theme code.
Verify full pricing tiers on the Shopify App Store.
Memberply is a lean, flat-rate membership app built for merchants who want predictable costs without revenue sharing. It charges zero transaction fees, which puts it in a different pricing category from apps that still take a percentage of membership revenue on lower-tier plans.
It’s a good option if you’ve already validated your membership model and want a no-frills tool that handles billing cleanly at a fixed cost, without the complexity of enterprise-tier platforms. While its review count is lower than more established apps, the merchant feedback that exists is consistently positive, particularly around ease of setup and the clarity of its billing structure.
Verify current pricing on the Shopify App Store.
Recurpay started as a subscription app and expanded into membership functionality. Its free plan (with a 3.5% transaction fee) makes it one of the most accessible entry points for merchants who want to add recurring revenue without an upfront monthly cost.
It’s a sensible first app for smaller stores that are still figuring out what their members actually want before locking into a more feature-heavy platform. The app covers the basics well: recurring billing, email integration, and a simple member-facing interface, which is often all a new membership program needs in its first few months.
Verify current plan names and transaction fee structure on the Shopify App Store.
Seal Subscriptions is best known as a low-cost subscription app, but it also supports membership-style recurring programs. It’s a practical pick for merchants who want a single app handling both use cases without a significant monthly investment.
The app has built a strong reputation in the Shopify community for its responsive development team and frequent updates, which gives it an edge over similarly priced alternatives that have stagnated. Brands selling a mix of physical subscriptions (regular delivery) and membership perks (access or discounts) often find Seal Subscriptions useful precisely because it doesn’t force them to choose between the two models.
Verify current pricing and plan limits on the Shopify App Store.
If you’re adding a simple recurring discount or a basic VIP tier, almost any app on this list will get you there. But if you’re building a program that actually retains members past the first 60 days, the difference comes down to what happens between renewal cycles.
Discounts alone don’t drive that. What drives it is the feeling that being a member is genuinely different from being a regular customer: store credit that accumulates, loyalty points that compound, a digital card in their wallet, and perks that arrive automatically. That’s what separates a membership that sticks from one that gets cancelled after the first month.
That’s where 99minds sits relative to everything else on this list. It’s the only platform that natively combines membership management with Shopify store credit, loyalty rewards, and gift cards in one system, without stitching together three or four separate apps. If you’re building for long-term customer retention, not just recurring revenue, that’s the distinction that matters.
Ready to get started? Try 99minds free and set up your first membership tier in minutes.
